In 2008 a programme called "Pedigree Dogs Exposed" made serious
allegations against several breeds of pedigree dogs. The German Shepherd
Dog was briefly mentioned in the programme. The Kennel Club, who took
part in the programme, were unprepared for the tone of these allegations
and were made to look incompetent and to have a lack of care for the
health and welfare of KC registered dogs. As a result of these
allegations the Kennel Club reviewed several Breed Standards and sent
out provisional new breed standards to the various Breed Councils.
German Shepherd clubs and leading breeders have always been
passionate about the health and welfare of our working breed so the
Breed Council, representing about 25 Kennel Club registered breed clubs,
and the two national clubs, the German Shepherd League of GB and the
British Association for German Shepherd Dogs formed an alliance called
the German Shepherd Partnership to represent the breed as a whole at
discussions with the Kennel Club. The partnership had some concerns
about these changes and arranged meetings with the KC to discuss and
clarify parts of the proposed new breed standard. Unfortunately, the KC
refused to have any discussions and changed the subject of these
meetings without any notice to the delegates. The new breed standards
were brought in without any consultation. Early this year each KC registered club holding Championship Breed
Show status was presented with a 10 point document which the Kennel Club
refer to as the "Undertaking". Each club was required to sign the
"Undertaking" or lose, forever, the chance to hold Championship Breed
Shows from 2012 onwards. The points include;- an admission that the
breed is unsound, that clubs will not run any event under the rules of
any other organisation (i.e. the SV or the WUSV) without the express
permission of the Kennel Club and that judges and stewards must be
"under contract in writing" to abide by the regulations regarding
"double-handling". Shortly after the "Undertaking" was issued a number
of clubs, who have a large obedience membership and hold Championship
Obedience Shows, asked the Kennel Club if they would have their
Obedience CC's withheld. The Kennel Club refused to confirm or deny that
Obedience CC's would be affected. On 20th February 2010 the Breed Council held an emergency meeting of
member clubs and members of the GSD Partnership to discuss the
"Undertaking". It became a heated discussion but eventually it was
decided that, as the home of the Breed is Germany and a large number of
those present had strong ties with the SV (German National Club) and
both national clubs were members of the WUSV (World Union of German
Shepherd Clubs), that item 9, regarding events under the rules of other
organisations, was unacceptable (and probably unlawful under monopoly
laws). The "Undertaking" was sent back to the KC with the request that
if item 9 was removed most clubs would sign. Unsurprisingly this request
was refused. The Chairman and Secretary of the GSD Club of Devon were still unsure
of the advice to give our members and the rest of the committee and it
was decided to have informal discussions with other breeders and
officers from other clubs at Crufts. At Crufts it became clear that most
of the clubs which had signed had done so to protect their Obedience
CC's and, while at the show, we had a glimpse of the future...... The
judge for German Shepherd Dogs had FOUR stewards sitting at the side of
the ring with clipboards making notes on his performance and,
apparently, the soundness of each dogs hindquarters (I have since heard
that these stewards could not agree on soundness!). The Best of Breed at
Crufts was Clokellys Lagos owned and bred by Carol Keen, a member of our
club. Lagos had been trained at our club since he was a puppy and we all
knew him and his siblings well. He was a deserving winner and we were
all very happy for Carol. This was shortlived as on the Crufts programme
on the More4 channel they showed slow motion footage of Lagos (moving
absolutely correctly) and Caroline Kisco, the Secretary of the KC, spent
several minutes rubbishing him, a dog which had been chosen by the KC
appointed judge as the Best of Breed. Needless to say, after much
criticism, the Kennel Club issued a press statement denying that they
had any control over the content of the More4 production. In our
opinion, if the KC Secretary does not represent the opinion of the KC
then who does? We have since noticed that the judges selected for Crufts
in 2011 and 2012 both favour the "Alsatian" type. Over the last couple of weeks we have consulted the breed members of
our club and discussed this important issue with the committee. The
outcome of this is below.
The Kennel Club have singled out the German Shepherd Dog from all of
the breeds mentioned in the programme "Pedigree Dogs Exposed" and have
taken no action against other breeds such as Cavalier King Charles
Spaniels and Boxers which have serious, even life threatening, genetic
problems. In our opinion the Kennel Club want to revert to the old "Alsatian"
type with all its problems in health and temperament, despite the
"Alsatian's" dwindling gene pool (these are still owned by many with
influence in the Kennel Club!) at the expense of the German or
International type which is recognised worldwide. The "Alsatian" is
laughed at in Germany, the home of the breed due to its
swan-neck, sagging back and over-angulation. The Kennel Club refuse to
drop the incorrect name "Alsatian" from its name for our breed, it is
"German Shepherd Dog" worldwide NOT "German Shepherd Dog (Alsatian)". The Kennel Club will go to any lengths to keep hold of its monopoly
on purebred dogs including unlawful actions, threats and outright lies. Lastly, the disgusting treatment of Mr Bob Kinsey, the German
Shepherd judge at Crufts and Carol Keen with her beautiful Best of
Breed, Clokellys Lagos, just to make a political point was
unacceptable. The Officers and Committee of the German Shepherd Dog Club of Devon
have decided, unanimously, NOT to sign the "Undertaking". James Apps, Chairman |